2009 Baseball
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Michael Sandman | Utica |
| Jerrod Ours | Utica |
| Rob Shaw | Utica |
| Jesse Hughes | Utica |
| Nate Chilcote | Fredericktown |
| Ty Fox | Fredericktown |
| Curtis Ruhl | Fredericktown |
| Sean Haines | Northridge |
| Ryan King | Northridge |
| Alan Witte | Northridge |
| John Burwell | East Knox |
| 2nd team |
| Derek Beaver | Utica |
| Joe Wheeler | Utica |
| Tyler Hathaway | Fredericktown |
| Keith Remley | Northridge |
| Nick McCament | East Knox |
| Jordan Hicks | Loudonville |
| Nick Mazgay | Centerburg |
| Kurt Sammons | Johnstown |
| Ryan Strouse | Danville |
| 3rd team |
| Joe Metzger | Utica |
| Cole Hoeflich | Fredericktown |
| Zak Harrod | Northridge |
| Colton Tucker | East Knox |
| Jordan Lance | Loudonville |
| Jacob Anderson | Centerburg |
| Colton Rosshirt | Johnstown |
| Casey Sloan | East Knox |