2009 Softball
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Christine Camp | Loudonville |
| Kaitlin Davis | Loudonville |
| Leanna Saldivar | Loudonville |
| Jerrica Young | Loudonville |
| Delaney Childers | Johnstown |
| Hannah Davis | Johnstown |
| Michelle Fairchild | Johnstown |
| Lindsay Rose | Northridge |
| May Howard | Utica |
| Hannah Matheny | Danville |
| 2nd team |
| Shelbie Rowe | Loudonville |
| Megan Scarberry | Loudonville |
| Amber Young | Johnstown |
| Sarah Heimann | Northridge |
| Abbie Corbett | Utica |
| Tracy Payne | Danville |
| Danielle Goeppinger | Fredericktown |
| Olivia Williams | East Knox |
| Honorable Mention |
| Kellie Derr | Loudonville |
| Lauren Elkins | Johnstown |
| Kimber Hazlett | Northridge |
| Tamra Londot | Utica |
| Kaleigh Conner | Danville |
| Taylor Keener | Fredericktown |
| Molly Grosscup | East Knox |