| 2009-10 Basketball |
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Skyler Simpson | Centerburg |
| Brandt Lambert | Centerburg |
| Thomas Hinkle | Fredericktown |
| Riley Cannon | Johnstown |
| Justin Dassylva | Utica |
| Luke Branstool, POY | East Knox |
| 2nd team |
| Drew Osborne | Centerburg |
| Shawn Block | Johnstown |
| Curtis Ruhl | Fredericktown |
| Joe Metzger | Utica |
| Skiles Haag | Loudonville |
| Conner Burke | Northridge |
| Weston Severns | Danville |
| Honorable Mention |
| Collin Bumpus | Centerburg |
| Ryan Logan | Fredericktown |
| Cody Green | Johnstown |
| Kyle Walton | Utica |
| Chance Lee | Loudonville |
| Khai Haralson | East Knox |
| Aaron Estep | Northridge |
| Nick Stover | Danville |