2009 Football
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Logan Awwiller | Fredericktown |
| Thomas Hinkle | Fredericktown |
| Austin Hoeflich - DPOY | Fredericktown |
| Tony Lybarger | Fredericktown |
| CJ Ruhl | Fredericktown |
| Nick Stacey | Fredericktown |
| Scott Cline | Utica |
| Jason Hoar - OPOY | Utica |
| Conner Mulligan | Utica |
| Derek Posey | Utica |
| Brent Allerding | Loudonville |
| Jordan Lance | Loudonville |
| Luke Weber | Loudonville |
| Riley Cannon | Johnstown |
| Brad Couts | Johnstown |
| TT Thompson | Centerburg |
| Drew Osborne | Centerburg |
| Zach Brewer | Danville |
| Heath Buckingham | Danville |
| Tyler Clement | East Knox |
| Colton Tucker | East Knox |
| 2nd team |
| Tyler Hathaway | Fredericktown |
| Jordan Levering | Fredericktown |
| Andrew Wildermuth | Fredericktown |
| Justin Newsome | Utica |
| David Raubenolt | Loudonville |
| Reed Franklin | Johnstown |
| Luke Donaldson | Centerburg |
| Quinton Ferenbaugh | Danville |
| Devin Wears | East Knox |
| Kolt McDaniel | Northridge |
| Honorable Mention |
| Matt Proper | Fredericktown |
| Jake Torrens | Utica |
| Adam Reidenbach | Loudonville |
| Jacob Kennedy | Johnstown |
| Dustin Irvin | Centerburg |
| Brandon Wilson | Danville |
| Jacob Morningstar | East Knox |
| Tony Stanley | Northridge |