| 2009-10 Basketball |
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Abbie Corbett, POY | Utica |
| Becky Orchard | Loudonville |
| Tamra Londot | Utica |
| Courtney Ryan | Loudonville |
| Claire Harvey | Centerburg |
| Aubrey Hazen | Danville |
| Courtney Dingess | Johnstown |
| 2nd team |
| Bridget Davis | Utica |
| Megan Scarberry | Loudonville |
| Michelle Crego | Centerburg |
| Hannah Mathews | Danville |
| Courtney Briegal | Fredericktown |
| Sierra Mazzaro | East Knox |
| Keilah Ketron | Northridge |
| Honorable Mention |
| Alexis VanHorn | Loudonville |
| Myranda Wolfe | Utica |
| Mackenzie Stoyle | Centerburg |
| Kaleigh Connor | Danville |
| Lyndsay Briegel | Fredericktown |
| Holley Sammons | Johnstown |
| Hayley Gray | East Knox |
| Lauren Cornwell | Northridge |