2009 Volleyball
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team |
| Allison Henthorn | East Knox |
| Sierra Mazzaro | East Knox |
| Courtney Briegel | Fredericktown |
| Kaitlyn Newkirk - POY | Fredericktown |
| Ann Sniechowski | Northridge |
| Tamara Londot | Utica |
| 2nd team |
| Emily Morris | East Knox |
| Lindsey VanHoose | East Knox |
| Danielle Goeppinger | Fredericktown |
| Genevieve Hager | Northridge |
| Amanda Wick | Utica |
| Kayla Peck | Centerburg |
| Courtney Ryan | Loudonville |
| Maria Hansen | Danville |
| Courtney Dingess | Johnstown |
| Honorable Mention |
| Emily Wells | East Knox |
| Lyndsay Briegel | Fredericktown |
| Jessica Johnson | Northridge |
| Bridget Davis | Utica |
| Macy Michel | Centerburg |
| Kaitlin Davis | Loudonville |
| Katelyn Walls | Danville |
| Kaitlyn Mooney | Johnstown |