| 2009-10 Wrestling |
| Final Standings |
| Loudonville | 248 |
| Utica | 197 |
| Centerburg | 151 |
| Fredericktown | 105 |
| East Knox | 104 |
| Johnstown | 82 |
| Northridge | 80 |
| All Mid-Buckeye Conference |
| 1st team | All-MBC | |
| Tim Stanger | 103 | Loudonville |
| Scott Spreng | 112 | Loudonville |
| Nolan Dilts | 119 | Fredericktown |
| Thomas Williams | 125 | Northridge |
| Dylan Wheeler | 130 | Utica |
| Trent Simmons | 135 | East Knox |
| Nick Carpenter | 140 | Utica |
| Jimmy Alexander | 145 | Centerburg |
| Scott Robinson, WOY | 152 | Johnstown |
| Dylan Bender | 160 | Loudonville |
| Alex Tuttle | 171 | Loudonville |
| Luke Weber | 189 | Loudonville |
| R.D. Williams | 215 | Johnstown |
| Bryce Stewart | 285 | Utica |
| Honorable Mention | All-MBC | |
| Rick Knuckles | 103 | Fredericktown |
| Andrew Mullin | 112 | Northridge |
| Cade Mickley | 119 | East Knox |
| David Vaughan | 125 | Loudonville |
| Cruze Parker | 130 | East Knox |
| Reed Hensel | 135 | Centerburg |
| Baxter Westover | 140 | East Knox |
| Dustin Walton | 145 | Loudonville |
| Tyler McCaskery | 152 | Loudonville |
| Derek Posey | 160 | Utica |
| Cody McGuire | 171 | Fredericktown |
| Alex Hudson | 189 | Centerburg |
| Brent Allerding | 215 | Loudonville |
| Austin Cary | 285 | Loudonville |